The Gethsemane Gators Athletic program offers sports participation to students in grades 3-8 in a variety of athletics and competitions. Gethsemane Lutheran School belongs to the Black Canyon Lutheran Athletic League and participates in events both within and beyond that league. 3rd grade students may participate in track, and students begin team sports in 4th grade.
Interscholastic Sports include
- Early Fall: Boys Flag Football / Girls Softball
- Late Fall: Boys & Girls Soccer / Girls Volleyball
- Winter: Boys Basketball / Girls Basketball
- Spring: Track & Field
- All Year: Archery